Looking back to examine some of the issues that helped shape the real estate landscape last year, provides us the opportunity to look ahead at how those trends might affect the industry in 2019.
Most evident in 2018 was the added liquidity brought about by the phenomenal growth of debt funds.
The record amount of capital raised by these funds continues to increase at a seemingly historic pace as institutional investors see debt as an opportunity to achieve attractive net returns with far less risk than equity investment, especially as we get into the late innings of the recovery. In addition, the re-emergence of CLO (collateralized loan obligation) allows managers to sell loans, typically kept on balance sheet, in the secondary market
This increased competition, not just among debt funds, but traditional lenders as well, has resulted in significant spread compression and higher leverage, as much as 85 percent LTV for well located projects with strong sponsorship. This phenomenon, where the gap between long- and short-term rates narrow and leverage creeps up, occurs toward cycle peaks and is a definite sign that we are in the very late innings of the recovery.
The other significant trend that has shaped the real estate markets this year is the climate of uncertainty that has impacted the industry both positively and negatively as a result of current administration’s policies.
For example, the trade war with China and the institution of tariffs have increased costs for developers, making investment in projects more difficult. This is especially true for developers of single and multifamily projects. Estimates from the National Association of Home Builders claim that homebuilders and those in the home remodeling industry almost exclusively used products from China, the primary target of the new tariff policy.
Rising costs on items like steel aluminum and granite slowed or even stalled development in markets around the country as developers had to rethink, in some cases redesign their projects as a result of uncontrollable increases in materials costs. Such volatility makes it very difficult to underwrite much needed housing, making it a point of focus of many lenders and investors today. The temporary truce between the United States and China suggests that hope springs eternal, but the recent volatility in the stock markets indicates that there is still much work to be done before a workable trade pact is finalized between the two countries.
While the new policy on tariffs impacted the industry somewhat negatively, the administration’s efforts to increase investment activity in economically distressed communities led to the development of Opportunity Zones, under the Tax Cut and Jobs Act. Opportunity Zones, which encourage investors to reinvest their capital gains in economically distressed communities in exchange for significant tax benefits is now attracting a lot of private capital — with estimates of as much as $100 billion being raised by newly formed Opportunity Zone Funds. According to research from Yardi, there are more than 8,700 areas in all 50 states of the U.S. that were designated Opportunity Zones by the Treasury Department. While offering tremendous opportunities for both residential and commercial development –– the deployment of that capital will take some time.
And on the regulatory side, the current administration has been a little steadier. Having chipped away at Dodd-Frank, life has become a bit easier for the small banks, although two months into the year, that has not yet happened in a wholesale way as of yet. It was also in 2018 that the White House and GOP members of Congress favored removing Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae from U.S. conservatorship, where it has been since 2008. While, it is unlikely that Congress will act in 2019 to privatize the GSE’s, the privatization of Freddie and Fannie signal that significant changes are on the horizon.
As we continue into 2019, the focus on debt funds and the geo-political roller coaster should continue. Lenders are still being diligent in their underwriting which should continue in a demonstrable way for some time, although we may see some further spread compression, as competition continues to increase with an abundance of capital seeking to finance a finite number of deals, to the benefit of borrowers.
It is worth noting that while retail continued to struggle in 2018, investors and lenders are getting to understand the asset class a lot better, giving cause for some optimism this year. We are beginning to see more categorization, a much more precise definition and stratification of both the retailers and the types of retail. That’s helping everyone, including investors, to start to understand what seems to work and what absolutely does not.
A 113-bed assisted living and memory care facility in Glendale has received $59.4 million in debt and equity financing, banking firm Dekel Capital announced Jan. 29.
The facility, Sage Glendale Senior Living, is being developed by Willis Development. When completed, it will have 81 assisted living units, 24 private memory care units and four semi-private memory care units.
East West Bank gave a $38.7 million construction loan. Dekel arranged the loan and provided $20.7 million in equity.
“The Public Policy Institute of California estimates that by 2030, more than one million seniors will require some assistance with self-care,” said Shlomi Ronen, principal at Dekel, in a statement. “In Glendale, where there are fewer than 20 facilities to serve a growing senior population of more than 200,000, this financing will help Willis Development meet the current and future demand for quality senior housing in what is the third largest city in Los Angeles County.”
Sage Glendale is at 509-525 W. Elk Ave.Read more
A Texas-based industrial real estate developer got a $34.3 million construction loan to finance a speculative logistics facility in Lakeland.
Xebec of Dallas plans to build a 537,000-square-foot logistics facility on a 60-acre site along Interstate 4.
Scheduled for completion in the fourth quarter of 2019, the logistics facility will have 36-foot clear height, 185-foot truck courts, 426 parking spaces for cars and 107 for containers.
Dekel Capital arranged the $34.3 million construction loan for Xebec’s speculative development in Lakeland.
A pension fund advisor originated the three-year loan with interest-only payments and a loan-to-value ratio of 85 percent.
“The availability of construction financing remains relatively constricted,” Shlomi Ronen, a principal of Dekel, said in prepared remarks. “However, the last-mile needs of e-commerce have reshaped the industrial real estate model and construction debt is available for new and urban infill development.” – Mike SeemuthRead more
The fourth quarter will be a borrowers market, thanks to a growing increase of new lending sources. This year, new lenders have routinely entered the market, particularly in the bridge lending space. As a result, lenders are loosening underwriting standards and reducing spreads in order to meet production goals, and this competition has allowed borrowers to dictate terms. This liquidity in the market will fuel activity in the fourth quarter as well as in through 2019.Read more
As we head into the 4th quarter of 2018 we are continuing to see the liquidity in the capital markets grow and reach a point of saturation where lenders are loosening their underwriting standards and reducing their spreads in order to remain competitive and meet production goals.
In the bridge lending space, the number of lenders continues to grow. In recent weeks we met with three new lenders that recently entered the debt fund space (we have lost track of the number of debt funds in the bridge lending space). All this growth in the bridge lending space is being fueled by a number of factors that have created a “perfect storm” for bridge lending; general institutional investor sentiment that we are late in the real estate cycle resulting in risk aversion and appetite for debt fund investments, financial regulation severely limiting the participation of finance companies in CMBS lending, and the resurgence of the CLO (“collateralized loan obligation”, a securitized warehouse lending facility), giving bridge lenders access to seemingly unlimited, cheap, capital to lend.
As competition for deals grows, we are seeing underwriting standards loosening. Today many lenders are willing to provide higher leverage at tighter spreads on senior loans than they had at the beginning of 2018. Although leverage is still nowhere close to 2006-2007 levels of leverage, it has definitely reached the highest levels we’ve seen in the last 10 years.
Here’s an example of a bridge lending program that was recently pitched to our team highlighting the aggressive nature of today’s bridge lending market: From a Bridge lender with a close affiliation with to a major life insurance company:
Lending Programs Expand
As the competition in the bridge lending space intensifies, a number of lenders are venturing into both construction financing and into mezzanine or preferred equity in order to remain active, maintain yields, and differentiate their product offerings. This is providing developers greater access to non-recourse construction debt at higher LTC ratios as well the ability to forgo utilizing 3rd party equity by layering in preferred equity or mezz.
Below an outline of terms for a recently launched construction lending program that provides higher leverage at lower pricing than had been available in the market until recently:
Non-Recourse Construction loan program:
In summary, 4Q 2018 will be a “borrowers’ market” with lots of liquidity to finance a wide range of investment opportunities at highly compressed spreads and higher leverage.
If you have a pending transaction in need of financing, contact a member of the Dekel Capital executive team to discuss how we can assist in getting your project over this hurdle and finding the best capital source for your needs.Read more
Prime Finance has written an $83 million floating-rate loan to finance the acquisition and stabilization of a Las Vegas office portfolio.
The loan, with a two-year term and three single-year exten- sion options, is backed by 444,000 square feet at seven proper- ties that Moonwater Capital bought from two separate sellers. Las Vegas-based Moonwater tapped Dekel Capital of Los Angeles to arrange the financing, which also included $21 million of preferred equity provided by Colony Capital of Los Angeles.
Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate merchant bank that specializes in sourcing and placing equity and debt for active middle market commercial real estate developers and investors, today announced it recently arranged financing on behalf of Moonwater Capital, founded by Ofir Hagay, for the acquisition of 444,194 SF across seven different buildings in the West and South Las Vegas submarkets. The combined portfolio provides one of the last large blocks of significant value add Class A office space within Las Vegas and positions Moonwater Capital as the market leader in the office market in Las Vegas. (more…)Read more
Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate merchant bank that specializes in sourcing and placing equity and debt for active middle market commercial real estate developers and investors, has successfully placed $14 million in bridge financing on behalf of Mountain Capital Partners and Willis Development to enable sponsors to retire existing construction financing and enable continued stabilization of Kingston Bay, an assisted living and memory care development located in Fresno, California, announced Dekel Managing Principal Shlomi Ronen.
Dekel Capital structured a $14.1 million, 24-month, interest only, bridge loan that will allow the sponsor to continue to stabilize the existing Assisted Living and Memory Care Facility. The facility provides an opportunity for the ownership group to create value through lease up of the remaining units. (more…)Read more
A joint venture between two California-based firms, Dekel Strategic Investors and Arrowroot Real Estate, has purchased Mueller Place, an 86-unit multifamily property in Austin. The new ownership will treat the investment as a value-add opportunity and renovate the unit interiors and property exteriors in an effort to bring rental rates in-line with the submarket.
Read more here.Read more
On April 3, with little fanfare, the Fed’s Alternative Reference Rate Committee (ARRC) started publishing the Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) that is slated to replace LIBOR in the US. This is an important first step in the transition away from LIBOR that is scheduled to expire in 2021. It is estimated that the US financial markets have $200 trillion of debt with LIBOR exposure; of this, approximately $1.1 trillion is commercial real estate (CRE) debt and securitized CRE debt. This pervasiveness requires a complex multi-year transition, but there is uncertainty as to the extent of progress that can be made before 2021.
In Multifamily Finance, Fannie and Freddie Are Still the Elephant in the Room. Shlomi Ronen emphasized that Congress and the FHFA ought to implement reforms with deliberation, changes that aren’t well explained clearly in advance could startle the market.
Regardless of where the agencies go from here, a survey of multifamily lending players underscored how high the stakes would be for any major reorganization. Shlomi Ronen, the founder of a Los Angeles debt brokerage that often arranges agency financings, Dekel Capital, emphasized that Congress and the FHFA ought to implement any reforms with deliberation, forecasting that changes that aren’t well explained clearly in advance could startle the market.
“Anything that’s done ad hoc or very abruptly is going to create a lot of anxiety,” Ronen said. “That will impact pricing.”
Adverse reverberations, in turn, could be cataclysmic in Ronen’s home state, he explained. Sky-high land prices and zoning restraints already make it difficult enough to make the math work on affordable housing projects. Things could get immeasurably direr, he said, if the sector’s go-to financing source disappeared.
“In California, it’s very tough to find sites to build affordable housing,” Ronen said. “The availability of financing makes possible what would otherwise be totally impossible.”
This article originally appeared on Commercial Observer.Read more
Dekel Strategic Investors is trading ground-up multifamily deals, where there may be some softness in rental rate growth, for value-add and core-plus strategies.
Dekel Strategic Investors, a division of Dekel Capital, is shifting its multifamily equity capital strategy to focus on value-add and core-plus deals. The firm is moving away from ground-up development, which it says no longer offers an attractive risk-reward profile.
The new strategy will continue to make small balance equity investments ranging in size from $5 million to $15 million using 65% leverage. We sat down with Shlomi Ronen, managing principal at Dekel Capital to talk about the strategic shift and what he is looking for in a deal. Read the rest of the story on Globe St.Read more
We recently celebrated the grand opening of Sage Desert Assisted Living and Memory Care, a brand new senior living community that is gearing up to help Tucson seniors and their families.
From the Arizona Daily Star:
With its dry climate and cultural attractions, Tucson is proving a strong market for developers of senior living centers. The boom in assisted living facilities that began locally about two years ago continues to draw interest from investors.
Tucson is a strong market for such developments because of weather and cultural activities, industry leaders say. Read the full article here.Read more
Two short months into 2018 we have seen a significant uptick in treasury yields along with positive economic data supporting continued Fed rate hikes for the remainder of the year. In the CRE lending universe however, the focus has been on has been on increased competition and decreasing credit spreads.
Here we will briefly touch on a couple of catalysts for this credit spread compression, as well, highlight a few lending programs that are relevant for our developer and value-add investor clients.
The peer group of bridge lenders focused on transitional projects continues to expand – by our count there are over 90 well-funded capital providers. This is a trend that we identified last year.
This opportunity for bridge lenders has been fueled by banks shifting their focus and capital to financing facilities for these real estate debt funds, as well as buying A-Notes on loans originated by these bridge funds.
Additionally, the muted CMBS origination volume has incentivized traditional CMBS shops to raise and deploy bridge capital as a tool to lead-sourcing tool for fixed rate lending.
Downward Pressure on Pricing – It’s a Borrower’s Market
Bridge lenders across the board have trimmed their spreads as much as a 100 basis points since Q4 – a clear reflection of the increased competition, lender financing options, as well as capital available at all leverage attaching points.
Further tailwinds for this lending has come from the CLO market re-activating in 2017. $109 billion of CLOs were issued in 2017 compared to $76 billion in 2016.
DEFINITION: A collateralized loan obligation is an asset-backed security which is backed by the receivables due on loans. Lenders package and sell their receivables on loans to investors in order to reduce the risk coming from potential loan defaults. Returns on CLOs are paid in tranches; that is, the individual loans backing a CLO have different maturities, and investors are paid out as each matures. Lenders offer higher interest rates to investors willing to buy CLOs backed by higher-risk loans (Farlex Financial Dictionary).
As well, the private REIT market has further buoyed the space, with a number of lenders forming private REITS to source cheap capital.
Behind the Curtain
While Libor and Treasury rates have gone up, lenders have compressed their spreads – keeping investors and borrowers focused on the all-in coupon. Lender return expectations have not gone up in conjunction with the rise in the indices (which is typical in a rising interest rate environment). We would attribute this to overall stability in the economy and the lack of higher yielding savings and or investment opportunities.
Lender Program Highlights
Multifamily Bridge Program
A leading credit-focused alternative asset management firm is offering up to 80% LTC bridge- financing on multifamily value-add projects, pricing starting at L+325. They can layer on additional mezzanine financing up to 90% LTC, priced at 12% with some upside participation. Nationwide.
One established fund manager has received a new allocation to deploy low-priced floating rate debt priced at L + 2.75% and up, at 70% to LTV. Up to 7-years of term, with a focus on taking out construction loans on new multifamily developments, or lease roll plays on office properties. Loan sizing at $20M+.
Life Company Execution
Life Co will take on “hairier” deals. They are comfortable going to 65% LTV and can offer shorter term 5-year fixed bridge money, $10M minimum check size. Open to look at properties with less than break-even cash flows. Pricing is typically at applicable Treasury + spread of 160 to 180.Read more
Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate merchant bank that specializes in sourcing and placing equity and debt for active middle market commercial real estate developers and investors, today announced it recently arranged financing on behalf of Moonwater Capital, founded by Ofir Hagay – for the acquisition of a 177,007 SF Class A office building located in the up and coming Northwest Las Vegas submarket. (more…)Read more
Dekel Capital co-brokers $122 million in JV-Equity and non-recourse Bridge Financing for sponsors Urban Offerings and ESI Ventures. Proceeds will be used to develop a 250,000 square foot Class-A Creative Office Campus in downtown Los Angeles’s Fashion District.
Dekel Capital Founder & Principal Shlomi Ronen contemplates the top trends that impacted the capital markets this year, and discusses how the major capital sources and real estate sectors performed.
2017 Capital Markets Year in Review
As the year comes to a close, we reflect on the major trends in the real estate capital markets and their impact on operating, investing and new development activity nationwide.
The capital markets continue to push forward with a full head of steam through year-end. Today there is ample liquidity and reliable competition among lenders at all levels of the capital stack. Geo-political concerns that dominated the first quarter of the year have abated, as the national economy continued to expand at a steady, manageable pace. As a result, this year we saw lenders enter new markets, expand their platforms to lend on niche product types, and take on more execution risk in order to maintain pricing and constrain LTV/LTC ratios.
On the institutional equity side, 2017 proved to be a challenging year to deploy capital, as liquidity compressed yields across the risk spectrum, new supply (especially in multifamily) tapered rent growth in most major markets, and concern over the longevity of the real estate cycle tapered equity investor appetite for investments that were exposed to significant market risks beyond two years from the initial investment date. On the international front, we saw the Chinese government curtail outflow of capital from China, which resulted in a palatable contraction of new Chinese equity capital in the market. On the other hand, we saw Japanese investors expanding their U.S. investment focus in a significant way.
Additionally, mobile home communities seem to be in favor with lenders nationally. The expectation is that the agencies will continue to provide strong tailwinds, with 2018 multifamily lending caps for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac projected to be at $35 billion for each enterprise, just slightly down from $36.5 billion in 2017.
Agencies (and some banks offering fixed-rate programs) are proposing increasingly attractive terms, in contrast to conduit lenders (further discussed below) who are restrained due to risk retention and consistent discipline from the CMBS B-piece buyers.
Institutional equity funds continue to express a strong appetite for both value-add and ground-up development opportunities in the industrial sector. Generally, industrial is wholly accepted and recognized as a critical component of a commercial real estate portfolio allocation. Equity investors and lenders understand the need to be involved on speculative, ground-up industrial deals in order to win business, as demand drivers show the strength of the containerized supply chain going forward.
The appetite for creative office remains strong, although with time horizon constraints due to the expectation of economic slowdown at some point in the next two to three years, investors in value-add projects are leaning heavily toward business plans that can be executed within 24 months. Longer business plans are being hyper-analyzed due to the expectation of a general slowdown in the economy thereafter.
Meanwhile, the commoditized grocery or big-box, anchored business plans based on population density and demographics are considered non-starters for most equity investors unless there is a compelling story (or basis).
A few new, non-securitized lenders have entered the fixed-rate space, looking to pick off the small dollar loan requests by offering fixed transaction costs and in-house servicing.
Overall, our recent conversations with players in the equity, debt and brokerage space have a familiar theme: everyone seems to have had a busy and productive year and is looking to take a few weeks off at year end to recharge for a competitive year ahead in 2018.
This article was originally published on Commercial Property Executive.Read more
The capital markets outlook for 2018 is positive, thanks to increased activity at the end of the year. Another good indicator: new private capital entering the market.
With banks constrained by regulations, more and more private lenders are stepping to up to fulfill investor needs. While these capital sources are unregulated, Shlomi Ronen, managing principal at Dekel Capital, says that underwriting standards are remaining conservative, and there is no cause for concern. We sat down with Ronen to ask him about him 2018 outlook, the activity from private lenders and what asset classes will be in the highest demand next year.Read more
SAN DIEGO/ LOS ANGELES, November 29, 2017. Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate merchant bank that specializes in sourcing and placing equity and debt for active middle market commercial real estate developers and investors, recently placed core-plus JV equity on behalf of Montana Avenue Capital Partners, LLC.
Proceeds were used to acquire and reposition a premier Class A, industrial flex multi-tenant park, encompassing a sprawling 13.6 acres, the Property consists of eight industrial flex buildings and one office building, totaling a combined 204,143 square feet, located in the greater San Diego market.
The property represented a unique opportunity to acquire a substantially stabilized flex office campus with the opportunity for future conversion into creative office.
Creative office conversions have experienced a flurry of leasing activity. A significant number of San Diego tenants have relocated from Class A office buildings to be in a creative office environment, making this a solid investment for our client and capital provider. Said Shlomi Ronen.
The buildings are uniquely designed with concrete and reflective glass facades, flexible designs, as well as extensive window lines, efficient loading areas and abundant surface parking. Ideally located within a short distance of the I-5 and I-805 junction, the office park is also set within a vibrant environment near restaurants, retailers, hotels, residential communities and many of the nation’s most influential tech and biotech companies.
Dekel Capital has been engaged in a combined $2 billion of structured transactions for developers, operators and investors, over the past 15 years.Read more
As everyone is busy working on their year-end closings, we will keep this one shorter than usual.
The capital markets continue to push forward with a full head of steam through year-end. There is reliable competition among lenders throughout the capital stack as the national economic drivers appear to have shed any geo-political factors that could dampen general optimism. Lenders are entering new markets for the right story.
On the equity side, the early cycle deals in primary and gateway markets have generally been picked over. Investors are open to new markets or product types as they chase yields and downside protection related to timing – avoiding business plans that require more than 24 months to execute.
Lenders and investors are open to exploring ‘story deals’ or ‘story locations’ in order to capture yields that are wholly priced out in any coastal or primary market.
Multifamily loans continue to be sized and priced to perfection in coastal locations. Borrowers are enabled as underwriting standards reflect valuations in the foreseeable future, despite the sentiment toward interest rate direction. Additionally, mobile home communities seem to be in favor with lenders today.
Agencies and banks offer increasingly attractive terms whereas conduit lenders are still restrained due to risk retention and discipline in CMBS B-piece buyers.
Industrial properties and creative office continue to feed off tail winds of fundamental change in consumer habits and desire to attract millennial tenants.
For industrial properties, institutional equity funds continue to express that they are underweight, which translates into strong appetite for both value-add and ground-up development opportunities. In general, industrial is wholly accepted and recognized as a critical component of a commercial real estate portfolio allocation.
For creative office, we have seen that the equity appetite for value-add projects leans heavily toward business plans that can be executed in 24 months. Longer business plans are being hyper-analyzed due to equity groups’ projections of macroeconomic risk and general slowdown in the economy.
Today, retail is all about buzzwords – with “right sizing the retail experience,” “experiential,” and “omni-channel” concepts popping up in our conversations with sponsors. The retail space is evolving, sparking curiosity in equity investors and caution from lenders. We are seeing valuations shift to indicate that equity can mitigate the sector risk in retail with smaller bets in this space.
Meanwhile, the commoditized grocery or big box anchored business plans based on population density and demographics are considered non-starters for most equity investors unless there is a compelling story (or basis).
Generally, everyone seems to have a full plate going into year-end. We continue to be cautiously optimistic for 2018.Read more
The Dekel team will be attending the ULI Fall meeting in Los Angeles, California next week.
Dekel Capital is actively sourcing both equity and debt capital for experienced investors targeting opportunistic, value-add and core plus deals.
We would welcome an opportunity to meet and discuss your investment focus for 2017-2018.
Select equity assignments:
Select debt assignments:
To schedule a meeting, please contact Shlomi Ronen.
CHARLESTON/ LOS ANGELES, October 16, 2017. Dekel Capital recently closed a $17 million non recourse construction loan for Xebec Realty Partners.. Proceeds will be used to develop a 262,080 SF state of the art Class A multi-tenant light industrial facility in North Charleston, South Carolina.
Dekel Capital utilized its extensive network to identify a lender that was capable of understanding the property’s unique positioning and attractive location, and could provide competitive loan terms.
“The development will bring much-needed Class A supply to North Charleston’s booming economy where recent transactions indicate significant growth and gave Dekel Capital and the lender a high level of confidence that this was a good investment.” said Shlomi Ronen.
The site is strategically located as the last developable site in the Palmetto Commerce Park, which features a variety of tenants including Boeing and Mercedes Benz. The site has excellent access to U.S. Interstate 26, the primary route of transit inland from the Port of Charleston and Charleston International Airport.
This deal reflects Dekel Capital’s ability to source capital for its developer clients as they expand into new markets. This non-recourse construction financing was structured as a “stretch senior” loan, which allowed for increased loan proceeds at attractive pricing. The firm has been engaged in a combined $2 billion of structured transactions for developers, operators and investors, over the past 15 years.Read more
LOS ANGELES/LAS VEGAS, October 4, 2017. Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate merchant bank that specializes in sourcing and placing equity and debt for active middle market commercial real estate developers and investors, today announced it recently arranged financing on behalf of Moonwater Capital, founded by Ofir Hagay – for the acquisition of two adjacent Class A, low-rise office buildings located in the burgeoning Southwest Las Vegas submarket. (more…)Read more
Dekel Capital was in attendance at the Western States CREF Conference a few weeks ago, where, over the span of two days, we met with over fifteen lenders and funds (and enjoyed a few nice meals, as well). The majority of the meetings were with institutional debt funds and banks active in the bridge lending space.
The phrase “it’s competitive out there” came up in most of our conversations. New lenders continue to enter the bridge lending market – filling the gap as banks continue to pump the brakes on lending (despite economic drivers and data continuing to show positive trending through the end of the year). Interestingly, the increase in competition is consistent across loan size profiles – with players entering in the sub-$10M loan size space, up through mid-market and larger loans.
One quick takeaway is that lenders are differentiating themselves via pricing and structure – as opposed to purely pushing leverage on senior loans, which was pervasive in the past.
We noticed a clear distinction between bridge lenders focused on lighter value-add deals with in-place cash flow versus lenders that were more comfortable with heavier construction execution and lease-up risk.
Ground-up construction is firmly within the sights of the larger debt funds, which are looking for $25M+ loan requests and offering a non-recourse option to developers.
The “stretch-senior” bridge and construction loan product is one place the lenders are working to differentiate themselves – moving from traditional leverage of 65% up to 85% – 90% of cost by layering in an internal mezzanine debt piece.
A couple of additional thoughts from the conference…
When borrowers are willing to take bank recourse loans, they are capturing around a 100-basis-point discount to debt fund pricing, as well as benefiting from lower transaction costs.
We believe the gap between fixed and floating rate loans will continue to compress as rate indexes such as LIBOR, Treasury and Swaps finally start to inch upward.
Lastly, as a whole, there was not the sense that everyone was avoiding discussion of potential elephants in the room – underwriting standards appear to be holding, and lenders are exhibiting a healthy level of caution for deals outside of primary or secondary markets.Read more
Dekel Capital Managing Director Shlomi Ronen discusses 2017 mid-year trends in real estate financing, including borrowers’ increased demand for alternative lenders keeping the balance between demand and new regulations.
As the first half of the year has come to a close, we look at trends in real estate financing, influencing commercial real estate investment and development.
As a result of the Dodd Frank risk retention rules that were implemented at the end of last year, the number of CMBS lenders has contracted significantly and the impact on the market has been muted due to lackluster borrower demand for CMBS loans.
According to Trepp, only 21 lenders have participated in securitizations this year and the five top lenders accounted for more than 61 percent of the volume. That is a significant drop from 2015, when 38 lenders contributed loans and the top five accounted for 43 percent of the volume. The large banks with balance sheet capacity have emerged as the beneficiaries of the new regulation as a result, because they can retain a risk piece.
Irrespective of this change, borrowers continue to demand CMBS alternative financing, as the CMBS loan origination process continues to be costly with loan terms subject to changes in the bond securitization market. In addition, loan servicers have been slow to document loan assumptions on asset sales, further frustrating borrowers. In the first half of this year we saw a few financing companies roll out fixed-rate loan programs designed to specifically target these issues. By either using their balance sheet or deferring securitization, these “CMBS alternative” lenders are offering a front spread lock on loans and will retain servicing for the life of the loan.
The agencies continue to be the go-to source for multifamily financing. With significant deliveries of Class A properties, we have seen the agencies become more selective and conservative in their underwriting on their “lease-up” programs. In some cases, they are pulling the lease-up program all together over supply concerns. Otherwise, they are aggressively providing both fixed rate and floating rate loans for stabilized properties.
Debt funds have been dominating the non-recourse bridge loan space this year. New capital raised last year has translated into increased competition that has both brought down the cost of bridge debt and loosened underwriting guidelines. In order to differentiate their capital and “win” new business, we are seeing a willingness by the debt funds to take on more construction risk, push leverage, and lend in secondary and tertiary markets; Oftentimes leverage is being increased through the use of internal mezzanine.
Additionally, we are seeing for the first time bridge lenders willing to commit to future funding without charging interest on the hold back amounts.
Construction lending capacity at the banks seems to be better managed this year as a result of tightened underwriting parameters, loan rationing and consequential filtering out of sponsors. We are seeing the upper limit on loan to cost at 70 percent, with most banks maxing out leverage at 65 percent.
The rule of thumb for sponsorship liquidity and net worth requirements used to be 10 percent of the loan amount, with the net worth being equal to the size of the loan. However, as developers take on more construction projects, banks are shifting toward 15 percent liquidity upwards of a 150 percent net worth. Credit spreads on construction loans, however, have flattened–we have not noticed any significant changes in spreads so far this year.
With respect to land financing, some banks are willing to provide pre-development or land development loans, but sponsors are being underwritten to take out construction financing, and only in cases where lenders are also actively trying to win the construction loan.
Product type comparisons show that street-level retail centers with legacy tenants, as well as mid-size and big box centers, are the lowest priority for bank lenders. Industrial properties are in high demand, especially in infill locations in major markets where last mile industrial properties are undersupplied.
Higher Leverage and Prefered Equity
Due to constraints on bank construction debt leverage, mezzanine and preferred equity funds have proliferated in the middle-market commercial real estate space, providing up to 85 percent financing on development and value-add deals.
Various funds are offering a stretch senior product in which they provide the full capitalization, with the senior loan component priced competitively with bank financing and removing one additional capital partner from the equation. These funds are typically non-recourse, which is more appealing to borrowers as they are focused on balance sheet management, given the banks increased focus on contingent liabilities.
This year we have seen JV equity funds shift their focus back to major markets as opposed to searching for higher-yielding investments in secondary or tertiary markets. Funds remain focused on partnering with experienced sponsors, especially as execution risk from a market cycle standpoint has become a greater point focus for them.
The capital markets continue to evolve with seemingly strong liquidity in all segments of the market. Recently proposed changes to banking regulation and pending rate hikes should not materially change the supply of capital in 2017.
Dekel Capital actively sources equity for developers in the industrial, creative office, multi-family space. We advise our clients to get out in front of their deals in terms of timing as the groups that are active are busy, which can affect closing timelines.
This article was originally published in the CPE newsletter 7-19-17.
The Dekel team will be attending PCBC at the San Diego Convention Center on Wednesday, June 28th. Dekel Capital is actively sourcing both equity and debt for experienced homebuilders and land developers targeting small lot, attached, and detached single family product.
We would welcome an opportunity to meet and discuss your capital requirements.
To schedule a meeting, please contact a member of the Dekel Capital team listed below.
As we reach the midpoint of 2017 with the 2016 presidential election now behind us, it seems like the “end of the current real estate cycle” has become a focus point for many of our investor/developer clients and capital providers. This industrywide focus on the “end” along with changing government mandates and market fundamentals may cause this cycle to extend beyond the “norm.”
Earlier this month we attended the ULI Spring Conference in Seattle, where the sentiment amongst conference attendees was heavily weighted towards the notion that we are in the later stages of the current real estate cycle. In light of this, the nature of the cycle discussion with investors, developers, and capital alike has been focused around risk exposure, protection of profits made so far in the cycle, and concern over new deals that might be exposed to the next downturn. For investors, this translates into acquiring assets with strong, predictable cash flow in more liquid primary and large secondary markets. For capital market participants, credit now rules the day, with more stringent underwriting parameters, as well as a focus on investing in or lending on projects that have less execution and market risk.
In addition to the cautious sentiment of market participants, we are seeing changes in government mandates and market fundamentals that are constraining new supply to the market. Recent changes to immigration and trade policies have helped drive up construction costs and prolong construction schedules by exacerbating labor shortages in the subcontractor trades and raising material costs.
In the multifamily sector, record deliveries of new supply have abated rent growth in major markets throughout the country. According to a recent report by Yardi Matrix, multifamily rents were up 2.0% nationwide in April, down 50 basis points from March and well below the 5.5% growth rate of a year ago. The combination of increased costs, longer construction schedules and abated rent growth are lowering return metrics thereby making the deals less appealing to developers and capital alike.
Contrary to the latter part of the last cycle, where many felt that market cycles were a thing of the past and excessive risk and leverage were the norm, the recent pullback by investors and capital combined with the changes in government mandates and market fundamentals leads us to believe that the current market cycle will extend beyond the norm. This should present some interesting investment opportunities for the contrarian investors in the market.Read more
The financing will provide for acquisition and horizontal development of much needed for-sale housing supply within in-fill LA, in close proximity to the Hollywood Park stadium development, which is the largest mixed use infill project underway in the Los Angeles metro area.
LOS ANGELES – 17 May 2017 – Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate merchant bank that specializes in sourcing and placing equity and debt for active middle market commercial real estate developers and investors, has secured $ 31.2 million of land financing for Harridge Development to acquire and start development on a fully-entitled townhome community in Inglewood, CA.
The site consists of 18 acres that had formerly been developed into a hospital and medical campus (now offline). The seller had originally secured approvals to develop 310 units on the site, Harridge is adjusting the existing residential plans for 228 detached condominiums as the newly rebranded “Grace Park”, which will be a gated community. The expected completion date coincides with the expected opening of Hollywood Park stadium in mid-2019.
Grace Park is exceptionally located in the heart of Los Angeles, just blocks away from the future football stadium that will be home to the Los Angeles Rams and the Los Angeles Chargers, along with The Forum.
Given the massive amount of development in the immediate area, coupled with the game-changing entry of not one but two NFL franchises to Inglewood, this site is perfectly situated to meet the pent up demand for infill housing, said Shlomi Ronen, managing principal and founder of Dekel Capital.
Harridge has a successful track record of residential entitlement and development in LA County. Harridge has previously acquired 17 residential and commercial projects in Los Angeles County, consisting of existing or projected entitlement for over 3,500 residential units, 1.2 million sf of commercial uses and 470 hotel keys.
About Harridge Development Group
Harridge Development Group is a real estate development company, founded in 2010, focuses on developing land for residential and commercial uses. They have extensive expertise in developing urban districts with single family, PUD, condominium, multifamily and mixed-use projects. HDG develops vacant or under-utilized sites, providing opportunities for community integration and creating places that become gathering points for the people both within and around their projects. Harridge focuses their efforts on the following Southern California markets: Hollywood, Silver Lake, Echo Park, San Fernando Valley, Glassell Park, Inglewood, West Los Angeles, Culver City, Venice, Marina Del Rey, Pacific Palisades, San Gabriel Valley, Santa Barbara, Echo Park and Koreatown. Harridge Development Group has a variety of different partners from large institutional investors to private high net worth individuals.
Harridge Development Group is swooping into Inglewood with a plan to build 228 townhomes on an 18-acre site just a mile from the Los Angeles Rams’ planned $2.6 billion stadium.
Dekel Capital in Century City provided Harridge with acquisition and development financing of $31.2 million.
Read more on Los Angeles Business Journal.Read more
We are looking for a diligent, communicative and detailed individual with a desire to take his/her commercial real estate finance knowledge to the next level. This is a great entry level opportunity to join a growing boutique real estate merchant banking company with both a private equity and capital advisory platforms with a unique culture and a supportive atmosphere.
Ideal candidate is a self motivated team player with a serious desire to work in the commercial real estate finance and/or private equity industry. You must be professional, highly organized, detailed-oriented, and able to handle multiple tasks in a fast paced environment and have a can-do attitude. This individual must possess excellent analytical, written, and verbal communication skills, and ability to prioritize.
Main Responsibilities include:
Compensation: Competitive compensation offered with a bonus component.
About Us: Dekel Capital, Inc. is a real estate merchant banking firm headquartered in Los Angeles. The Company specializes in capital advisory for all asset type throughout the United States as well has a private equity platform that invests in multifamily development projects.
This is a unique entry level position to work in both real estate private equity and capital advisory.
Job Type: Full-time
Required education: Bachelor’s
Required experience: Real Estate Financial Modeling: 1 year
Location: Century City, Los Angeles
Please send your cover letter and resume to [email protected]
The Dekel team will be attending next week’s Crittenden National Real Estate Conference in The Westin, South Coast Plaza in Costa Mesa, California on April 27. Dekel Capital is actively sourcing both equity and debt capital for experienced investors targeting opportunistic, value-add and core plus deals.
We would welcome an opportunity to meet and discuss your investment focus for 2017.
Select equity assignments:
Select debt assignments:
To schedule a meeting, please contact a member of the Dekel Capital team listed below.
Senior Vice President
| Sandy Schmid
We are attending several commercial real estate events in the upcoming months. Please reach out to a member of our management team to set up a meeting during the events listed below.
Crittenden National Real Estate Conference, this three day event brings together Real Estate professionals and offers educational sessions as well as networking events.
Location: The Westin South Coast Plaza
Date: 26-28 April
ULI Spring Meeting, an exclusive, ULI members-only event bringing together top decision makers and industry experts from every sector of real estate.
Location: Washington State Convention Center, Seattle
Date: 2-4 May
CREFC Commercial Real Estate Finance Summit, networking events and finance sessions presented by leading industry participants.
Location: West Fairmont Miramar Hotel & Bungalows, Santa Monica, California
Date: 9-10 May
PCBC, dedicated to advancing the art, science and business of housing, PCBC is the largest homebuilding tradeshow representing the west coast region.
Location: San Diego Convention Center, San Diego
Date: 28-29 June
CMBA, 20th Annual Western States CREF Conference.
Location: Wynn Las Vegas — Las Vegas
Date: 6-8 SeptemberRead more
Among all the market updates and meetings at the Mortgage Bankers Association Conference last month, the one revealing note was that a handful of New York-based bridge debt funds will be opening up offices on the west coast, specifically in Los Angeles.
These debt funds continue to see opportunities to gain market share in a growing niche, as bank financing for the acquisition and recapitalization of transitional assets continues to be curtailed in the face of cumbersome regulatory frameworks.
Beyond expanding their footprint, the bridge debt fund peer group is also enlarging the strike zone – taking on smaller deals, reemerging aggressively as an option for properties with little in-place cash flow, and looking at smaller markets – a change from the sense in the market as recent as six months ago.
With the increased competition in the lender peer group, our clients are benefiting from tighter spreads and lower fees, specific to west coast deals where having boots on the ground allows lenders to fully understand the story and its risk mitigants.
A couple of capital market factors are helping propel this growth in bridge lending. (In order for these debt funds to achieve their targeted low to mid-teens return, they leverage their capital with either bank financing or securitized vehicles, CLOs.)
Firstly, banks are playing a significant role, as more banks focus their lending capacity (away from construction lending) to providing increased leverage and relaxed terms to the debt funds – expanding the amount of lending capacity of these debt funds who are typically capitalized via committed funds or allocations for hedge funds.
Secondly, the securitization market for floating rate debt has returned (CLOs) and offers additional access point for debt funds to recycle capital.
Lastly, as a mitigant to lower origination volume expected in 2017 as a result of the volatility experienced in 2016 and the new risk retention rules that came into effect recently more CMBS lenders are offering floating rate, short-term debt products as a lead-source for fixed rate CMBS execution.
Dekel Strategic Investors, a division of Dekel Capital, has hit $100 million in equity financing, a major milestone for the firm, which has focused on joint venture equity for multifamily deals.
The firm launched its equity program three years ago and strategically focused on joint venture deals and multifamily properties.
“This milestone really puts us on the map now,” Ronen tells GlobeSt.com. “When you are a start-up, there are always concerns about your ability to execute, and now having done $100 million, we are a real player in the space.”Read more
The market chatter at the end of 2016 centered around the pending wave of CMBS maturities, as well as, what anyone’s guess would be as to the new administration’s early moves regarding regulatory changes or rolling back Dodd Frank and other policies that had constrained the credit market in recent years, which had particularly held back the reemergence of the banking sector.
The President signed an Executive Order in the first week of February to scale back the Dodd Frank regulations that were installed as a reaction to the financial crisis. Related to this Executive Order, we expect to see more details in the coming months with regards to the loosening of regulations that the banks have had to decipher and navigate in recent years. We anticipate that this easing of banking regulations should result in lower borrowing costs for consumers and businesses alike, as well as, will inject additional liquidity in the lending market.
That said, the New Year has brought with it tightening of loan underwriting standards for specific to construction loans – as bank credit officers are directed to pump the brakes due to allocation and exposure to construction loans (specifically Multifamily) after the run up in the past few years. As well, many banks have been active in the multifamily sector in recent years and thus are looking to diversify their exposure to other product types.
We are seeing loan underwriting criteria continue to evolve whereby Banks are underwriting un-trended rents and have increased their stress test levels on both debt yield requirements and debt service coverage ratios. This is lowering construction loans to size to 60-65% of cost in comparison with last year loans were sizing to 65%-70% of cost.
In the face of these constraints on bank debt leverage, coupled with the pending wave of maturities of CMBS loans, a number of new mezzanine and preferred equity lenders have proliferated in the middle market commercial real estate space.
We have identified several of these mezzanine and preferred equity groups that are willing to take on construction risk and are layering their capital behind construction lenders, enabling our developer clients to push leverage up to 85% of cost, at yields that range between 9 and 14 percent.
These mezzanine groups have been calling on us as they have capital allocations to deploy and are eager to expand their network of senior bank lenders and developer sponsors with which they transact. As well, a handful of capital sources are offering “full stack” construction financing up to 85% LTC as competitive rates, offering decreased deal costs and execution risk.
To conclude, despite the loosening of oversight that is anticipated from Washington this year, Banks have taken a more conservative approach to construction lending in 2017. Borrowers that still need higher leverage construction financing (beyond 60-65% of cost) do have a solution that we can help facilitate through the addition of mezzanine or preferred equity to the capital structure.
Despite all the noise out of Washington since the inauguration, so far things seem to be business as usual for our clients and the capital partners that we work with. We are not hearing about anybody making drastic changes to their capital markets plans for 2017 as a result of the election.
If you have a pending transaction in need of financing, contact a member of the Dekel Capital executive team to discuss how we can assist in getting your project over this hurdle and finding the best capital source for your needs.
Dekel Strategic Investors, a division of Dekel Capital focused on development of multifamily and senior housing has invested over $100 million in equity.
For inquiries contact Shlomi Ronen, Managing Partner.
For information on investment criteria: dekelcapital.com/dsiRead more
We are attending the Mortgage Bankers Association CREF / Multifamily Conference February 20th and 21st in San Diego. We would welcome an opportunity to meet and discuss your capital strategies for 2017.
Find out more about our recent multifamily transactions and other deals by visiting our news section.
To schedule a meeting, please contact Sandy Schmid.
Dekel Capital is ready to discuss your unique capital challenges at the NMHC 2017 Annual Meeting in San Diego.
With proven expertise in capital market advisory and private equity, we look forward to starting the conversation on how Dekel Capital can structure and source financing to provide the certainty of execution to close your next multi-housing deal.
Through our proprietary JV-equity program we also make select investments and partner with local developers in ground-up multifamily, senior housing, and student housing developments.
To schedule a meeting, please contact Sandy Schmid.Read more
LOS ANGELES/TUCSON, Calif.—Jan. 10, 2017— Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate merchant bank that specializes in sourcing and placing equity and debt for active middle market commercial real estate developers and investors, has placed $25 million in financing for the construction and development of Sage Tucson, an assisted living and memory care development located in the Northwest Tucson Casas Adobes submarket.
The deal was capitalized with a $17 million construction loan arranged through Dekel Capital’s advisory practice and $8.4 million JV-Equity funded by the firm’s proprietary equity fund, Dekel Strategic Investors (DSI). Construction on the 106-unit, Class A senior housing development, located at W Orange Grove Road and broke ground in late 2016, construction to last 18 months.
“Sage Tucson presents a first-rate opportunity for investment due to the exceptionally strong rental market in Tucson, the superior location and the remarkable demographics.” Said Shlomi Ronen, managing principal and founder of Dekel Capital.
The Sage Tucson assisted living and memory care facility will contain a total of 106 units consisting of 86 assisted living units and 20 memory care units. The project will feature a 2-story structure with a fitness center, community room, craft room, beauty salon, recreational lounge, theater, therapy room and outdoor courtyards on a 9.55-acre site.
Sage Tucson has street frontage on West Orange Grove Road, which is an east/west artery that connects to the I-10 Freeway and State Route 77 and has a daily visibility of 23,000 cars. The facility is also located within two blocks of the Northwest Medical Center and in close proximity to the Foothills Mall, located 2 miles from the property, which includes a roster of national rental tenants.
Sage Tucson was DSI’s 3rd JV-equity investment with development partner, Willis Development, and their first senior housing investment in Arizona. DSI and Willis Development previously partners on two senior housing developments in California: Kingston Bay in Fresno, which is currently in lease up, and Sage Mountain in Thousand Oaks which broke ground Mid-2016.
DSI, a division of Dekel Capital, provides equity capital to real estate developers engaging in multifamily, senior housing, student housing and retail development projects. To date, DSI has invested over $100M across 11 deals and is actively looking for more investment opportunities.
About Willis Development:
Willis Development was founded by Wayne Naphtal with the intent to develop senior living properties. Mr. Naphtal has over thirty years of accomplished real estate development experience from acquisition to project disposition. Prior to forming Willis Development, Mr. Naphtal founded First Family Homes and led the full cycle of development from entitlement to disposition for multi-family residential properties in excess of $500 million. In addition to Sage Tucson, Mr. Naphtal has recently completed a 120 bed Assisted Living + Memory Care facility in Fresno, CA and is under construction on a 130 bed Assisted Living + Memory Care facility in Thousand Oaks, CA.Read more
Next year, the final round of CMBS debt from the last cycle will mature. In total, it is about $86 billion in CMBS debt that will need to be refinanced, and according to Shlomi Ronen, principal and founder of Dekel Capital, that is great news for the capital markets because it will create “forced transaction volume,” and will create a lot of opportunities. To find out more, we sat down with Ronen from an exclusive interview to talk about the state of the CMBS market, what to expect next year and if the push for early refinance for CMBS borrowers has helped to ease the burden.Read more
Dekel Capital will be attending the 14th installment of the Annual Winter Forum on Real Estate Opportunity & Private Fund Investing, January 18-20, 2017, The Montage Resort & Spa, Laguna Beach, CA.
Last year, Dekel Strategic Investors, a division of Dekel Capital, invested $30 million in JV-Equity across three projects. We would welcome an opportunity to discuss your equity needs for your next multifamily or senior housing project.
As 2016 comes to a close, we find ourselves at a precipice of two significant events in the RE sector to bear in mind for 2017.
Over the past 5 years, there has been a lot of discussion and preparation for the wave of 2007 vintage CMBS loan maturities and the looming opportunities it presents. More recently, as the result of the nomination of President Elect Trump, we are seeing a changing political and regulatory climate. Recent insights into his administration’s proposed policy seem to be focused on bank deregulation, as well as, divestment from government sponsored agencies; Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. The confluence of these two significant events present an opportunity to make 2017 a banner year for real estate transactions.
At the beginning of 2015 there was roughly $230 billion of CMBS loans set to mature by 2017, raising concern in the capital markets as to how these loan maturities would be absorbed and handled come 2017. According to CREFC, out of the estimated $230 billion originated in 2007, there is approximately $87 billion scheduled to mature next year. This figure is far more manageable and much lower than anticipated a year ago.
Of the $90 billion, the retail and office sectors make up the largest volume of loans coming due, approximately $30 billion and $24.6 billion respectively, along with high LTVs (over 80%). These high LTV loan maturities, originated during an era of looser underwriting standards, will present an opportunity for investors and mezzanine lenders alike as conventional financing using todays underwriting standards will not be sufficient to refinance the outstanding loan balances in their entirety.
Conversely, this may also result in increased delinquencies in CMBS loans, foreclosures, and eventual REO sales which will take time to resolve and bleed into 2018 and 2019.
With the risk retention regulations coming into play with respect to CMBS, we expect CMBS loan origination to be further constrained in 2017 unless there are changes to the regulatory framework. While the regulations, which require lenders to retain a stake in loans originated, will ultimately help overall CMBS loan quality, the cost of doing so will ultimately be passed onto the borrowers. This may result in CMBS becoming less competitive and alternative sources of financing stepping in.
The President Elect’s new treasury secretary, Steve Mnuchin has been vocal recently about de-regulating the banks and exiting out of the ownership of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. While we have not been privy to the details of the new administration’s plans there has been some discussion that Dodd-frank (the framework governing risk retention laws, the Volker Rule, and reserve requirements) will be revisited.
Loosening of banking regulation resulting in increased liquidity from banks would be positive for the real estate sector. There are many unanswered questions as to the process and how the administration will handle exiting ownership from government sponsors agencies, Fannie and Freddie. These agencies have been the backbone to cheap capital which has helped sustain the high transactional activity in the multifamily sector. If the spin-off of Fannie and Freddie reduces to the availability of capital and increases pricing, there will be significant implication to pricing of MF properties.
As we approach 2017, the confluence of these two events have the potential to make 2017 a banner year in terms of transaction volumes for the real estate industry.
If you have a pending transaction in need of financing, contact a member of the Dekel Capital executive team to discuss how we can assist in getting your project over this hurdle and finding the best capital source for your needs.Read more
Dekel Capital has successfully placed $20 million in bridge financing for the acquisition of an obsolete retail center in Granada Hills, CA (the “Property”).
The 8+ acre site is situated in a desirable location for a mixed-use development in the San Fernando Valley. The existing retail center is currently 79% occupied, lacks a conventional anchor tenant and has considerable deferred maintenance. As a result the Property was not suitable for traditional bank financing. Dekel Capital structured a $20 million, 12-month, non-recourse bridge loan with Buchanan Street Partners that will allow the sponsor to redevelop or reposition the existing retail center.
The San Fernando Valley submarket is one of the tightest multifamily markets in Greater Los Angeles area, presenting a prime opportunity for redevelopment within a supply constrained submarket, said Shlomi Ronen, managing principal and founder of Dekel Capital.
Of the lender, Buchanan Street Partners, Shlomi Ronen said “they were quick to understand the business plan as well as the value creation that our client realized while under contract to acquire the Asset. This gave us and our Client great confidence in their ability to execute on the loan request.”
For additional information please get in touch with Barbara Barnes – Gravesteijn, our media contact.
Dekel Capital has secured $ 6.9 million of joint venture equity financing for Haven Realty Capital (“Haven”) to acquire and reposition La Ventana Apartments in northwest Las Vegas.The project’s financing structure includes $6.9 million in Dekel Capital-sourced JV equity, a floating rate senior loan from Freddie Mac and sponsor equity.
“Through a number of introductory meetings led by Dekel, Haven became a known entity to key institutional equity groups in the multifamily sector,” said Shlomi Ronen, founder and managing principal of Dekel Capital.
Dekel started introductory meetings with a number of equity partners and Haven early in the process which showcased Haven’s experience and interest in acquiring assets in California, Nevada and Arizona. These meetings allowed equity groups the opportunity to better understand Haven’s business plan when the La Ventana project was presented.
Located at 2901 N. Rainbow Blvd. in North Las Vegas, the 256-unit La Ventana Apartments complex is set to undergo an extensive value-add renovation to meet the demand of a growing professional tenant profile in the immediate area. Haven expects to complete the renovation and stabilize the property over 36 months.
“With its thriving entertainment and hospitality-based economy, in addition to recent developments in its technology and healthcare sectors, Las Vegas is becoming one of the nation’s most desirable and affordable metropolitan areas,” said Sudha Reddy, co-founder and managing principal of Haven Realty Capital.
“Haven has extensive investment experience in the Las Vegas market and believes La Ventana Apartments will provide a significant value-add opportunity.”
The La Ventana Apartments acquisition marks Haven Realty’s third multifamily acquisition in Las Vegas over the past 12 months. The sponsor also operates a portfolio of 600 single-family rentals in Las Vegas and an additional 1400 single family homes in CA and IL.
La Ventana Apartments is in close proximity to the newly expanded Mountain View Hospital, four retail shopping centers and has exposure to strong traffic counts of 20,500 vehicles daily. The property, built in 1989, incorporates one- and two-bedroom units in 17 separate standing buildings on 13.5 acres. With 401 parking spaces, La Ventana Apartments features on-site amenities including in-unit washers and dryers, built-in kitchen appliances and a semi-private entrance in addition to private balconies and patios. The two-story complex also offers a swimming pool and spa, fitness center and children’s playground.
Dekel Capital was in attendance at the Western States CREF Conference in Las Vegas earlier this month, where we met with capital sources across the lending spectrum to get updated insights on lending programs and trends in today’s capital markets.
The current sentiment is that lenders have recovered from the general market turbulence that reverberated through the industry in the first quarter of the year. Both bridge lenders and fixed rate lenders are now providing fluid supply of debt to meet borrowers’ needs through the end of 2016, albeit at tighter leverage levels than 12 months prior and with a greater focus on in-place cash flow or pre-leasing.
The evolving gap in the market for bank lender construction financing (as bank lenders have met allocation levels and are reserving capacity for existing clients) has allowed private debt funds to partially fill this void and become more active players in the space. These traditionally “bridge” lenders aim to differentiate themselves by providing flexible construction loan structures and providing asset management and loan servicing in-house – offering some respite for borrowers who are more accustomed to bank pricing for construction financing. Additionally, given the pullback in leverage by bank construction lenders, construction mezzanine debt and preferred equity investments are being offered by private funds with leverage up to 85% LTC achievable for commercial real estate, and potentially higher for multifamily projects. In some cases, lenders are offering a combined senior + mezz “stretch senior” structure that offers a single capital source for borrowers with larger, heavy value-add and construction projects (20M+).
CMBS lenders have seen recent deals priced wider in the face of the regulatory changes pending. Recent AAA securitizations have priced from 102-108 and BBBs have ranged from 525-625. Given the trending among borrowers to lock in rates on longer-term financing, new fixed rate debt mezzanine players are also entering the market, offering longer-term products to complement CMBS (as well as life company and bank loans).
We highlight here a few loan programs that stood out in our discussions with capital sources at the conference:
Mezz/Pref Equity Construction Financing:
Deal marks $100 million funded through Dekel Capital’s JV equity platform
LOS ANGELES/THOUSAND OAKS, Calif.—Sept. 22, 2016—Dekel Strategic Investors (DSI), a proprietary equity fund of Dekel Capital that provides equity capital to real estate developers engaging in multifamily and senior housing development projects, has placed $16.1 million in equity for the development of Sage Mountain Senior Living. The 130-unit, 58,154-square-foot assisted living and memory care facility will be located in Thousand Oaks, California.
With the closing of this deal, DSI has now invested over $100 million in equity, since the platform was launched in January 2014.
“DSI was formed to facilitate deals such as this, to fill the recognized gap in the capital markets for equity investment between $4 and $10 million,” said Shlomi Ronen, managing principal and founder of Dekel Capital. “We continue to see a need for this valuable platform, particularly as demand grows for quality senior housing projects of this size throughout the U.S.”
As the baby boomer generation continues to age, the U.S. Census Bureau projects the population of Americans over the age of 65 will nearly double by 2050. As a result, quality senior living options for the aging community are in high demand, and projects like Sage Mountain Senior Living meet this need.
Sage Mountain Senior Living will house 98 assisted living units, along with 32 memory care units within a secure memory care wing. Each unit in the four-story building will average 453 square feet and will be fully handicap accessible, equipped with extra wide doors and handicap bathroom fixtures. Amenities for the project include a salon, fitness room, library and a 41-space subterranean parking garage.
“Sage Mountain Senior Living presented a prime opportunity for investment in new construction within a supply-constrained submarket, where similar care facilities are not being built,” said Ronen. “This, along with the strong comps in the surrounding area, gave our investors confidence in the property’s potential for stabilization and success.”
The property’s accessibility off of U.S. Highway 101 provides great visibility for the project, while its quiet cul-de-sac location offers privacy for its future residents. Sage Mountain Senior Living is also located in close proximity to major retail centers, including The Oaks, a regional shopping mall, and The Promenade at Westlake.
Construction started in early September 2016 and is tentatively scheduled for completion by the beginning of 2018.
The Federal Reserve announced on Wednesday it will not raise its benchmark interest rates and expects to raise rates more slowly in the coming years. The Fed has decided to stick with its cautious approach to adjusting monetary policy, as recent economic indicators have continued to be mixed. With only 38,000 jobs added in May, job growth has declined, yet economic growth has shown signs of improvement. As such, 15 of 17 policymakers project no more than two rate hikes this year, and six of those officials expect just one rate hike for the remainder of 2016. The Fed will meet again in July and September.
Global economic uncertainty and the recent Fed announcement have promoted a flight to safety that has caused the 10-year treasury yield to close at 1.594 percent, its lowest closing level since December 2012. The negative yielding bonds from Asia and Europe have also played a part, as these investors continue to purchase U.S. Treasury Bonds and, in turn, drive yields lower.
Regulatory Impact on Housing Affordability
New banking regulations that are coming into effect are restraining construction lending and the delivery of supply. In turn, these restrictions, combined with increasing demand for multifamily housing, are further impacting housing affordability issues prevalent in core urban markets. In a time when home ownership is at already historic lows, people are increasingly relying on multifamily rentals for housing. With this evolving development, existing project owners are benefiting, while renters and developers are being heavily burdened.
In the first quarter of 2016, non-seasonally-adjusted U.S. home ownership rates dropped to 63.5 percent both on a quarterly and yearly basis, down from 63.8 percent at the end of 2015 and 63.7 percent in the first quarter of 2016, according to St. Louis Fed data and generally falling in line with the U.S. Census estimate. Currently, home ownership rates are at their lowest since 1967, with similar rates last seen in 1985. The current sustainable dynamics indicate a faltering market, reflecting the overall weakness in economic growth and inefficiency of monetary policy.
Amidst declining home ownership, the multifamily segment of the market looks relatively bright and fundamentals remain relatively strong. The National Association of Home Builders’ Multifamily Production Index (MPI) shows a reading of 58 in the first quarter of 2016 compared to a reading of 59 in 2015, still above the long-term average of 49 since the index was started in 2003. The MPI is a weighted average of current production indexes for low-rent, market-rent and for-sale units, and can vary from 0 to 100, where any number over 50 indicates more builders report stronger rather than weaker conditions. In May, REIS reported the nationwide occupancy rate was 96 percent in April, down 10 basis points from March, but flat with the first quarter average.
In an effort to make banking safer after the 2008 market crash, we are now seeing the effects of financial rules taking shape, specifically in the form of the Basel III banking regulations and HVCRE rules, which went into effect at the beginning of 2015. As mentioned in our April article, banks have become increasingly concerned with their risk exposure to CRE loans, in particular construction loans, and are tightening their underwriting standards. In certain cases, they are reserving capacity solely for long-standing relationships. Their balance sheets are even more constrained, further limiting the amount of money going into new development deals, impacting availability and pricing, as they become more conservative in terms of leverage and, in some cases, ask for partial recourse.
While these regulations work to make banking a safer practice as a whole, they are making it more difficult for developers to obtain the financing necessary to move forward with development projects and deliver supply amidst declining vacancy rates, rising rents and pent-up demand. Many core urban markets already face significant supply constraints in the form of a lack of developable land and community opposition. These constraints have a tendency to increase as new projects consume land and developers build resistance. Market participants can now expect the added burden of banking regulation to result in the slowing of multi-housing construction and exacerbating of affordability problems.
Certainly, financial regulators and the rules they enforce are intended to look out for the safety of depositors and their funds. The institutions they regulate are regional, national and international in nature and not designed to respond to local market conditions. However, there are ways to recognize local conditions. For example, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac determine conforming home mortgage size limits based on zip code, signaling a willingness and capacity to accommodate for local conditions.
Benefit and Burden
While the housing shortage and affordability component is widely seen as a burden, it directly benefits owners and developers who are ahead of the game. Those who own rental housing or already have projects under construction have less future supply competition to worry about. As the supply of affordable housing is outpaced by demand, more would-be home buyers are turning to rentals, allowing landlords to raise rents accordingly. Additionally, developers who already have loan commitments or projects under construction have a distinct advantage and can capitalize on the shortage, with higher rents and ease of lease-up due to lack of new product.
Developers seeking financing for projects in their pipeline are now having to expand beyond their known lending sources, find other banks and consider alternative financing in the form of debt funds. With tighter construction lending conditions becoming the new reality, we are seeing higher borrowing costs, which are passed on to the end-consumer in the form of higher rents and greater delays in bringing new product to market. Additionally, developers might not meet anticipated project returns due to higher costs of borrowing and may even decide to postpone projects altogether.
As a group, renters might be households that cannot afford to buy, cannot qualify for a home mortgage or simply choose to rent by lifestyle choice. In high-rent markets, finding housing is difficult enough for many of them, as they sometimes pay over 50 percent of annual income on housing alone. As such, many renters fall into the category of severely cost-burdened households according to the Department of Housing and Urban Developments’ (HUD) rule which uses a maximum of 30 percent of annual income to determine if housing is affordable, which is not realistic in supply constrained markets. Collectively, these households ultimately suffer when additional impediments to supply are added to their list of challenges.
Sandy Schmid has joined Dekel Capital as a Director where he is focused on new business relationships, investor relations, and raising equity and debt for investors and developers.
With over 10 years of real estate experience, Schmid’s background in development and finance brings a hands-on understanding of each client’s real estate assets and their unique capital needs. Prior to joining Dekel, he served in leadership positions at several firms within development and finance, touching almost every aspect of the real estate spectrum throughout his career.
Previously, Schmid directed acquisitions and managed development at Blue Ridge West, LLC, a boutique developer of multifamily and hospitality properties, in addition to underwriting prospective and controlled projects as a development associate at SummerHill Apartment Communities, where he was instrumental in raising debt and equity capital for the company’s projects. He has also worked at Wells Fargo’s Real Estate Banking Group as an assistant vice president/relationship manager. Schmid began his real estate career as an architectural draftsman, working on custom residential and commercial projects.
Schmid earned both his MBA and MRED from the University of Southern California and completed his undergraduate studies at Trinity College in Hartford, CT.
He is a licensed California Real Estate Broker.Read more
Since the beginning of 2016, our conversations with capital sources have made it abundantly clear that concerns over a tighter global financial outlook and the implementation of new regulations have caused a shift in lender sentiment. This comes at a time when the strong demand for new construction loans is consistent with 12 months ago, but the supply of capital is constrained as lenders react to allocation issues as well as the Basel III regulations.
As banks become increasingly concerned with their exposure to risk in CRE loans, specifically construction loans, they are tightening their underwriting standards and, in certain cases, reserving capacity for existing borrowers.
Here are a few tips you need to know to attract the shrinking pool of construction loan dollars:
Banking Relationships Matter
As the high volatility commercial real estate (HVCRE) rules take shape and developers continue to reach out to banks for their construction needs, relationships are becoming increasingly important as construction loan dollars are constrained. Banks, for the most part, are now restricted and preserving any remaining construction capacity for existing client relationships or requiring a good reason to entertain new prospects.
In addition, the request for a strong deposit relationship has returned to the scene. As always, we feel it is part of our role to provide our clients with options and multiple good banking relationships to avoid the “meet and greet” phase when they’re pressed for time.
Click here for additional information on HVCRE and exceptions for qualifying loans
Answer Questions Before Lenders Ask
Banks that do have remaining capacity for construction loans are now receiving such an influx of new requests that the length of the review process has drastically increased. This has also caused banks to become more selective, even on “cleaner” deals.
While the length of the review process remains a constant variable, we are able to cut through the noise by targeting specific lenders that we know, through our experience, have closed similar deals and currently have the ability and proper lending programs to meet that specific request. In a constrained market, it’s important to show potential lenders that you’ve already addressed any concerns in your request in order to combat future issues.
And just as we maintain good banking relationships for our clients, we also understand the unique nuances of development and construction financing. As such, we can best position their project in a concise, complete financing package that respects lenders’ limited time, which assists in receiving a quick “yes” or “no” that is so critical to each project’s success.
So as the supply of construction loans dollars decreases, we find that matching the right project to the right lender, leveraging relationships and recognizing the impact new regulations have on lending practices, will make all the difference in approval of our client’s next construction loan.
Recognize the Role CMBS Plays
As discussed in our previous Capital Markets Insights article – we predicted CMBS loan volume to decrease in 2016 largely due to the widening of spreads; Dodd-Frank, which requires 5% retained by loan originator for 5 years; and Regulation AB. Regulation AB, which will also go into effect in January 2017, will hold senior executives personally liable for loan performance and make them certify they are unaware of any undisclosed negative aspects. For this reason, we may see banks directly originate CMBS loans to hold the 5% requirement and to avoid loan kick outs. We may see banks tighten warehouse lines to mitigate risk as CMBS originators are working to discern the full impact of the new regulations.
The increased risk weight for banks as it relates to high volatility commercial real estate (HVCRE) went into effect at the beginning of this year. The result is that all acquisition, development and construction (ADC) CRE loans must be reported separately from other CRE loans and are to be assigned a risk weighting of 150% for risk-based capital purposes – above the typical requirement of 100%. This will have a significant impact on banks’ capital ratios and ability to lend at historic pricing levels. It is important to note that these restrictions are related to real estate, specifically construction, and not the macro-economy.
However, there are some exceptions for qualifying commercial ADC loans allowing a risk weighting of 100% if the following requirements are met:
The HVCRE requirements are changing the way lenders reserve for construction lending and impacting availability and pricing, including becoming more conservative in terms of leverage or asking for partial recourse. Lenders are more focused on leverage and execution. Many lenders are now topping out at 60% LTC for construction, with a heavy focus on pre-leasing. Other lenders are also pulling back on specific property types – like hospitality, spec office, retail – and have decided to pause construction loans altogether, unless the deal is highly compelling or a repeat borrower.
We have arrived at an inflection point in which lenders are becoming more sensitive to construction and more focused on clean deals to avoid scrutiny by internal credit committee and regulators.Read more
Shlomi Ronen, founder and managing principal at Dekel Capital, was featured in the National Real Estate Investor’s article Get Ready for Liquidity Crunch in Late 2016? on March 11th, 2016.
The article discusses what is causing the choppiness in the CMBS markets, and alternatives where borrowers are heading to refinance pending loan maturities. As well as, how these events could affect the capital markets in the second half of 2016.
The full article can be found hereRead more
In this edition of Capital Insights, we dive into what is causing the choppiness in the CMBS markets, and alternatives where borrowers are heading to refinance pending loan maturities. As well, we consider how these events could affect the capital markets in the second half of 2016.
Choppiness in the CMBS Markets
CMBS issuances year-to-date as of February 12th have been a paltry $6.5 billion, compared to $13.7 billion for the same time period in 2015. Given the robust (or at least steady) flow of positive national economic employment and spending figures, we ask – why are CMBS originators pumping the brakes?
Unlike the last cycle in which lax underwriting precipitated the initial slowdown in the CMBS market, in this case there are various external factors that are making it hard for CMBS lenders to price new loans competitively and commit to terms prior to closing.
First, the number of CMBS lenders has shrunk. As spreads continued to widen through Q4 2015, various players missed their break-evens in the December 2015 securitizations, and were pushed out of the market. The insight from our recent survey of CMBS lenders is that the market will “barbell” as mid-sized origination shops are squeezed out by large originators that are securitizing on a frequent basis, and niche lenders that are bound to specific product types or geographies. The focus is now on execution, after a volatile Q4 in which the spread on benchmark CMBS paper blew out, squeezing profits and causing higher spreads on new loans.
Second, CMBS bond buyers are still finding their feet in the New Year. Spreads for the “rated” tranches of the recent CMBS securitizations are being pushed wider as these bond buyers look to the relative value of widened spreads on corporate bonds and demanded the same (or higher) returns from CMBS bonds. Had this just been typical “noise” in the market, CMBS spreads would have pinched back in or stabilized at a wider spread, but in this case the pending regulatory requirements (set to take effect in December 2016) for the “unrated” B-Piece of the CMBS securitizations is leading to a greater uncertainty in nascent business model of CMBS 2.0, as CMBS originators and private funds reconfigure the capital used for B-Piece purchases. The new regulations will require CMBS originators to keep a stake in their originations and hold the risk on their balance sheets for 5 years in an attempt to discourage risky lending and keep their “skin in the game”.
As a result, CMBS originators are treading cautiously – pricing loans with enough “cushion” and regressing to primary markets. Subtle innovations include a “spread lock” mechanism for large loan borrowers, as well as, lenders raising capital to acquire their own “unrated” B-Piece tranches in separate vehicles. Borrowers who would traditionally look to a CMBS refinance are looking elsewhere, as re-trades on pricing and terms in the turmoil of year end have now readjusted their expectations on leverage and focus on certainty of execution.
CMBS Alternatives / Liquidity Crunch in Late 2016
Dekel Capital recently conducted a comprehensive survey of the banks, debt funds, and life companies that are soaking up the pending loan maturities that one year ago would have gone to CMBS. Market sentiment is positive as debt funds are seeing more business as borrowers look for better execution and/or 36 months of runway to decide to either sell the product or place fixed rate pricing on it. Additionally, there are life companies with products pushing leverage to 70% LTV. These newer products can rate lock at application and are priced competitively against CMBS pricing.
Market input is that the 2016 lending capacity for debt funds, life companies, and banks may be deployed by later summer, leading to a potential liquidity crunch should deals come up against a pending loan maturity. The equity groups we speak with on a regular basis have echoed this sentiment, modeling their own exit scenarios and are shifting away from investing in vacant office conversions or retail repositions involving a significant period of downtime, with the focus in-place cash flow.
Capital to Highlight:
Dekel Capital has identified a Life Company with ample capital to deploy for long-term fixed rate loans. The loan program can push leverage to 70% LTV, fixed or floating rate terms are available at competitive pricing.
If you have a pending transaction in need of financing, contact a member of the Dekel Capital executive team to discuss how we can assist in finding the best capital source for your needs.Read more
In the first few weeks of 2016, we have seen the stock market retreat due to global economic and geopolitical uncertainty. This uncertainty has promoted a flight to safety that, in turn, has caused treasury yields to drop 28 basis points since the start of the year. While the drop in treasuries is generally a good thing for real estate capital markets, investors and developers, it has had a profound impact on CMBS lenders who have not seen this kind of rate volatility in quite some time.
In this month’s publication we discuss how construction lenders, CMBS originators and B-Piece buyers are adjusting to the volatility in the bond market and the pending implementation of new regulation, as well as the federal banking agencies’ hawkeyed statement for risk management in commercial real estate lending.
Construction & Bridge Lender Survey
Dekel Capital recently conducted a comprehensive survey of construction lenders. Market sentiment is positive and the expectation is for another busy year. Market volatility in the past six months is recognized but market specific growth drivers remain robust and new projects are being underwritten to trended market rent and absorption levels.
The national banks, regional banks, and debt funds that fueled the boom in construction and heavy value-add projects through the end of 2015 have not lost momentum, maintaining a strong appetite for construction lending with a focus on residential, creative office, and hospitality projects. With an eye on adjusting exposure among product types, lender feedback in the new year indicates a desire to deploy more capital into student housing and senior housing, as well as, for retail – assuming strong preleasing in place prior to breaking ground. Specifically, one regional lender has indicated they have a new allocation of $100M of non-recourse construction financing for new student housing developments. Recourse lenders are maintaining their sizing parameter at 75% of project cost, with non-recourse lenders coming in slightly tighter.
Bridge lenders are also seeing increased activity as borrowers with maturing CMBS loans are looking for alternatives in the short term. Bridge funds are well capitalized and have the capacity to lend across all product types at competitive floating rate pricing.
CMBS Lenders Adjusting to Volatility
The continued volatility of the bond market has affected borrowers and places pressure on originators that have to hold loans on their books for any protracted period of time – 30 days or more. This has been a distinct advantage for the larger originators as they are frequently out to market faster than the smaller origination groups.
Yesterday, the 10-year treasury fell below 2% for the second time this month, a drop of 28 basis points since the start of the year and its lowest level since October 2014. The sharp decline was matched by increases in AAA spreads as investors in the top rated tranches hit their yield floors thereby causing CMBS spreads to widen accordingly, and many CMBS lenders to adjust their quoted spreads in applications. This spread adjustment has hurt borrowers in process with CMBS loans who would usually benefit from declining treasury rates.
While 2015 proved to be a difficult year for a number of CMBS originators, CMBS is still a great option for high leverage, long-term, non-recourse and cheap debt. However, considering the recent volatility and new regulatory pressures impact on originators profitability, we expect there to be some consolidation in the number of CMBS lenders in 2016.
B-Piece Buyers Required to Hold Positions Long Term
The risk-retention regulations, part of the Dodd-Frank financial regulations that ensure B-piece buyers hold B-pieces for at least five years, amongst other things, are set to take effect in December 2016. As this date approaches, many buyers and investors are gaining a clearer idea of how the regulations impact them, specifically the five-year hold mandate after purchasing the bottom five percent of a securitization.
Investors usually retain the unrated notes and single B-class for their high yields and fee-rich, special-servicing rights and look to sell single some B-notes and low-yielding B-class to infuse fresh capital for new purchases. However, the regulations stipulate that B-pieces must be sold intact, unless two-thirds of the collateral balance has been retired which can be more than five years due to limited amortization in conduit deals and loan extensions. This results in B-piece buyers retaining the bonds for the life of the loan or more and in some cases, lock up a B-piece buyer’s investment for more than a decade. As we get closer to the regulation start date, we may see B-piece buyers changing to a long-term hold strategy and setting up strategic long-term funds.
Agencies Statement on Prudent Risk Management for CRE Lending
As 2015 concluded, federal banking agencies issued a joint statement cautioning the commercial real estate industry and explaining how they will be proactively monitoring financial institutions using risk management practices. The decision came as a result of the agencies’ increased suspicion that CRE’s recent lending growth might not be sustainable long term. The market, driven by historically low cap rates and rising property values, has surged and banks have been lowering underwriting standards to keep up with competition.
The new, prudent risk management practices may slow down CRE lending in 2016 as banks begin to tighten standards under the pressure of federal agencies’ supervision. However, this close monitoring of banks will give non-regulated lenders a prime opportunity to increase their volume throughout the new year.
Click here to read the joint statement.
If you have a pending transaction in need of financing, contact a member of the Dekel Capital executive team to discuss how we can assist in finding the best capital source for your needs.Read more
Regulatory changes and market movements have dominated the news cycle for capital markets this month, so we’ve outlined the top items you need to know for what lies ahead in 2016.
Present: Interest Rate Hike
The U.S. economy entered a new era this week with the Fed’s decision to increase short-term interest rates for the first time in nearly a decade. This move did not come as a surprise to the market. After months of deliberation and allusions to a possible hike by members of the Fed, capital markets have already priced in the new 0.25%-to-0.5% rate increase. In their statement Wednesday, the Fed left the door open for further rate increases next year as the economic indicators continue to strengthen, and the economy reaches the 2% inflation target.
In its rational to initiate an increase, the Fed cited that the low interest rate environment has met its intended goal to stimulate the economy. The allure of the low interest rate environment in particular drove an influx of capital into the market from both foreign and national investors seeking to capitalize on the increasingly healthier US economy.
Past: Setting the Stage in 2015
Capital providers looking to fund investments flooded major gateway cities and primary markets, which resulted in investor focus and financing options shifting to secondary markets. The economic drivers in secondary markets have remained at healthy levels, along with strong jobs data and employment growth, giving lenders more comfort and resulting in a strong lending outlook for the upcoming year.
The conduit lenders and agencies each hit a minor roadblock in 2015. Conduit spreads widened significantly over the summer, driven by fluctuations in the Chinese stock market as well as an abundance of issuance. Agency lenders surprised the market early in the second-quarter of 2015 by curtailing lending and widening spreads due to lending capacity limits, with some exceptions for affordable and smaller properties.
Future: Looking to 2016
How the wall of CMBS maturities will impact the market remains one of the biggest question marks for capital markets moving into 2016.
We can see from the chart below that CMBS issuance saw positive year-over-year growth from Q1-Q3 2014 to the same periods in 2015; however, the market is holding its breath for the wall of CMBS maturities coming down the pipeline, unsure of its impact. Coupled with risk retention requirements beginning in 2016, this may impact the positive momentum built in the last few years and restrict the amount of capital available.
Considering all of this, 2016 is shaping up to be an environment framed by an increasingly constrained flow of capital and higher interest rates – albeit minor compared to the zero rate climate we’ve grown accustomed to for the past seven years. Increased regulatory stipulations will most likely affect leverage and pricing for traditional commercial real estate financing, and may push borrowers to less-regulated sources of capital to fill the gap. An uptick in interest rates could translate into lower cash returns for investors acquiring commercial properties; however, since a hike signals an improving economy, investors may be able to make up the difference with higher rental rates in a market that could support such an increase.Read more
In 2015, we saw a continued low interest rate environment, the implementation of Basel III regulations and a multitude of new entrants to the market in all areas of the capital stack. Looking ahead at 2016, we will see additional constraints put into place on capital flows. These increased regulatory stipulations and constraints on capital will effect leverage and pricing for commercial real estate and have borrowers seeking non-regulated sources of capital to fill the gap.
Risk Retention Requirements for CMBS Lenders
As required by the Dodd-Frank Act, the final credit risk retention regulations for asset-backed securities (ABS) is set to be implemented in 2016. This may limit the amount of capital that is available as well as increase the cost of CMBS capital, if it is implemented as written. Groups will have to shift their perspective and investor base to attract longer-term capital due to the five-year hold mandate.
The regulations essentially require a securitizer of ABS to hold 5% of the credit risk of any asset collateralized by issuance for a minimum of five years from the closing date of securitization. On the positive side, well-capitalized funds are being set up to take on the additional risk. While that will help with the availability of capital, it will ultimately have a negative impact on spreads.
FHFA Keeps GSE Multifamily Cap at $30 Billion Each and Adds New Exclusions
In October 2015, the FHFA maintained Fannie & Freddie’s lending cap at $30 billion each in 2016; the same amount as 2015. However, a new quarterly review will be instituted to ease concerns over possible cap breaches and allow for potential adjustments, given current market conditions.
In addition to the exclusions added in 2015 to prioritize affordable housing, low-income apartments in rural areas, senior housing loans, small multifamily properties targeting low-income tenants and energy efficiency improvements will also be excluded in the year to come.
In April of 2015, Fannie and Freddie widened spreads and tightened underwriting in an effort to slow down their lending programs, which were on track to exceed their annual limit of $30 billion by the third quarter of 2015. If by year end, the agencies have reached their cap and a deal does not meet the list of exclusions, companies with balance sheet capabilities could have a distinct advantage by providing financing and holding the loan on book until the cap is refreshed in 2017.
EB-5’s Future at Stakes
The EB-5 visa, a method of obtaining a green card for foreign nationals that invest money in the U.S., was created in 1990 with the intent to bring investments that would in turn create jobs in the U.S. However, the program began receiving more attention as a result of the financial crash.
Critics say the visa program is poorly regulated, susceptible to fraud and provides an unfair “fast pass” to citizenship for the wealthy. Over the years, some developers have even benefited from this alternative and cheap source of capital by bending provisions meant for rural or high-unemployment areas.
The program was originally set to expire on Sept. 30, 2015, but was extended until Dec. 11, 2015 when Congress will vote on further legislation for the program. California Senator Diane Feinstein, who recently voiced her disapproval for the program and stated it “puts a price on citizenship,” will likely use this opportunity to call on Congress to end the program.
The EB-5 visa program has grown over 700% from $321 million in 2008 to $2.56 billion in 2014, and is expected to generate $4.4 billion in foreign direct investments for 2015. In 2014, a total of 10,692 EB-5 visas were issued, with 85% of those allotted to Chinese investors.
To some, this could be a wakeup call to steer away from programs that rely on government programs and regulation for real estate funding.
The quality of capital seems to be increasingly constrained by regulatory stipulations. Banks are constrained by regulations, the agencies have been capped and risk retention requirements on CMBS may create an artificial cap on CMBS lending. Naturally, a portion of the mortgages have been paid off through defeasance due to low rates but the wall of CMBS maturities is coming and many are concerned with what volume can be met by these highly constrained capital sources. From this, we may see more non-regulated finance companies stepping into the lending space as the banks and CMBS shops that provide over 50% of capital on an annual basis are having their capital limited.Read more
With holiday decorations popping up around town, we are reminded that year-end is just around the corner. While many traditional lending sources – banks, life companies and agencies – have their hands full, active private money lenders are well-capitalized and can fund your year-end acquisition opportunities. These lenders are hungry to meet their own lending goals and have quick-close capabilities to fund deals in as little as two weeks. Dekel Capital has identified a high leverage balance sheet lender that can execute your next financing by year-end.
If you have a pending transaction in need of financing, contact a member of the Dekel Capital executive team to discuss how we can assist in finding the best capital source for your needs.Read more
Fed Delays Rate Increase Bringing Continued Stability and Low Rates To CRE
For the past several months, the commercial real estate industry has been awaiting the decision that would impact not only its bottom line, but also its momentum towards a stronger recovery. While labor markets have strengthened, downward pricing pressure from the decline in oil and commodities has kept inflation below the Federal Reserve’s target. In fact, the Fed took the path of least resistance and voted to keep interest rates at 0.25 percent as inflation remains below the two percent mark.
At the press conference following the Fed’s decision, Federal Reserve Chairwoman Janet Yellen echoed Stanley Fischer’s thoughts during the Jackson Hole Summit last month. Fischer explained that unemployment is not what’s slowing inflation. The lagging inflation is rather a product of a drop in oil and commodity prices, and a rise in the dollar. The strength of the dollar allows for cheaper imports but impedes exports. The Fed offered no insight in a recent press release as to the timing of the rate increase but will do so “when it has seen some further improvement in the labor market and is reasonably confident that inflation will move back to its 2 percent objective over the medium term,” according to the issued statement.
The 16-1 vote against raising rates today was the first time since January that Fed members were not unanimous in their voting. The decision will be tabled until their next meeting, where projections show 13 policy makers seeing higher rates by the year end. Based on the forecast, we are likely to see only one increase in October or December, down from two in the previous forecast.
The graph below was released in September and shows when FOMC participants find it appropriate to raise interest rates.
The Dot Plot below was released in September and shows where FOMC participants predict the federal funds rate to be. It is important to note that the dot plot is a tool that provides insight as to how the committee members felt at the September meeting.
What does this mean for commercial real estate? The Fed’s decision brings stability and continuation of low interest rates for construction, bridge, and floating rate loans. Additionally, the pressure on bank earnings net interest margin should encourage lenders to increase real estate lending.
Dekel Capital at Western States CREF Conference
While at the Western States CREF Conference in Las Vegas, Dekel Capital saw an increase in new capital providers seeking to gain a toehold among the already competitive field of CMBS Lenders, Bridge Debt Funds, and Bank Lenders.
Non-recourse bridge lending on both cash flowing and non-cash flowing value-add plays is aggressively pricing in the high 4 percent’s to low 6 percent’s across all product types, at up to 80 percent of project costs. The market for non-recourse construction lending is also becoming more fluid at leverage up to 60 percent – 65 percent, as new players enter the space. The new “new money” at CREF was mezzanine debt at up to 85 percent LTV behind CMBS and Agency financing, fully co-terminus with the first TD. This mezz debt prices in the low double digits.
Lastly, banks are also expanding their lending programs, offering fixed rate loans that serve as lower cost options to CMBS and Agency debt, in some cases with more flexible pre-pay structures.
The beginning of 2015 has been eventful for the real estate capital markets. While the jury is still out on what comes next, here are the top five indicators of what’s been and what’s coming:
GE Capital exits the lending business
In April of this year, GE exited the banking business by spinning off GE Capital, the higher risk $500 billion finance business that was 42 percent of company profit last year. The company has already sold $26.5 billion worth of office and CRE debt to Blackstone Group LP, Wells Fargo, and other investors, and is expected to fully divest as early as 2016. Part of the $9 billion portfolio Wells Fargo purchased from GE Capital included loans for manufactured homes and communities, a space dominated by Wells Fargo ($7 billion in loans since 2004) and GE Capital ($6.2 billion loans since 2004). Now, as the clear leader in manufactured home lending, Wells Fargo plans to expand the division and has recently hired Matt Krasinksi and Lew Grace, two GE Capital veterans, to lead the charge. Other lenders have been working towards capturing the $10 billion GE was originating per year of both bridge and permanent loans.
Fannie and Freddie shift gears after high production volume in Q1 and Q2
Also in April, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac slowed down their multifamily lending program because both government sponsored enterprises were on track to exceed their annual limit of $30 billion each by Q3 2015. The annual lending caps, which only apply to market rate apartment loans, were established in 2013 by the Federal Housing Finance Agency to encourage more private capital in the market. Fannie Mae issued $10.4 billion in Q1 and $14.5 billion during Q2 in multifamily mortgage-backed securities, while Freddie Mac’s multifamily lending volume hit $10 billion for Q1 and $13.1 billion for Q2. This high production volume has been driven by low interest rates, large loan sizes and overall higher demand for apartments as well as deferred business from the end of 2014.
Fannie and Freddie slowed down process by tightening their underwriting and increasing spreads. Currently their focus is on “affordable housing” and properties under 100 units, both of which are excluded from the cap.
Basel III’s impact on construction lending
BASEL III is a global bank framework that proposes further banking regulation on capital adequacy, stress testing and market liquidity risk. Basel III was created in an effort to repair the financial crash and restore a proper financial system. It forces banks to hold substantially more capital, or shrink their footprint, which reduces the effect they would have on the financial system if they were to fail.
The overall significance of Basel III is that with banks improving their capital ratios, there will be less liquidity in our global capital system. Because of this, smaller or weaker banks might find it difficult to raise capital, which could ultimately result in banks exiting the market place, merging or being acquired.
High Volatility Commercial Real Estate: Under Basel III, regulators created this new category which applies to acquisition, development and construction loans requiring higher capital reserves. This is making these loans more expensive for banks to fund. Furthermore, the new rules require a 15 percent minimum cash equity requirement to avoid a High Volatility designation, as well as max 80 percent LTV on the finished product. Specifically, the appreciated value of the land does not count towards the equity requirement, only the cash paid for the land or the original basis.
Global economy slows, the outlook on short-term rates
The recent free-fall of the Chinese financial markets created some of the worst volatility in our capital markets since 2009. This market volatility has scared investors, which resulted in a flight to safety, causing the 10-year treasury to drop below 2% for the first time since April of this year, compressing the treasury yield 20 basis points in the past week. The global economic slowdown will cause the Federal Reserve unanticipated aggravation leading up to their September 17th meeting. In light of this, the overwhelming market expectations that the Fed would start raising rates in September is becoming more of a 50/50 proposition.
The Dot Plot below was released in June and shows where each Fed member predicted federal funds rate to be. It is important to note that the plot is not official, but rather a tool that provides insight as to how the committee members felt at their June meeting.
New lending sources bridge the divide for needed financing
New lending sources have entered the market to fill the gap as both banks and agencies face the lending hurdles described above. “Stretch senior” lending programs provide bridge loans up to 75 percent to 80 percent of cost for value-add repositioning of existing assets. Specific groups with dry powder are focused on medical office, creative office and multifamily. Mezzanine and Preferred Equity providers are showing an appetite in coming in behind these bridge lenders and pushing leverage up to 90 percent of cost. In a bid-to-win business, these mezzanine and preferred equity groups are lowering their minimum amount to $1 million in some cases. Lastly, various bank lenders are aiming to fill the capacity left by the agencies by offering attractive long-term, fixed rate, non-recourse loans.
As we enter into the second half of 2015, it is important to note that there are disruptive market movements on the horizon. Clearly a change in interest rates will have a major impact, and with the regulatory environment in its current state, new lending sources will most likely continue to enter the market in order to bridge the gap left by banks and agencies. 2015 is shaping up to be an interesting year.Read more
We had a great time at the Bisnow Los Angeles Capital Markets Summit and enjoyed the Bridge & Mezz update moderated by our very own, Shlomi Ronen.
Pictured above from left to right:
Shlomi Ronen, Managing Principal |Dekel Capital
Larry Grantham, MD | Calmwater Capital
Scott Shepherd EVP |OneWest Bank
Jeff Friedman Co-CEO |Mesa West Capital
In January 2014 Dekel Capital launched Dekel Strategic Investors (DSI), a JV-equity platform to provide equity capital to real estate developers engaging in multifamily, senior housing, student housing, and retail development projects. Over the past 18 months, the DSI has invested over $65 million across nine projects throughout the United States. DSI will continue to fill the recognized gap in the capital markets for equity investment between $3 and $10 million and is targeting a total of $100 million of JV-equity investment by year end.
Shlomi Ronen noted, “We continue see a window of opportunity in the multi-family and senior housing sector that is a result of the improving US economy and unmet tenant demand for quality housing in multiple primary and secondary markets throughout the US.”Read more
Max Friedman, SVP at Dekel Capital, was quoted in PrivcapRE’s article Mezz Debt’s Steady Advance in Risk by Christopher O’Dea on March 2, 2015.
Read the full quote below:
“More players are entering the mezz space, resulting in increased
competition to win deals,” says Max Friedman, senior vice president at
Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles–based merchant bank focused on
commercial private equity real estate and complex financing structures.
“GPs are expanding their lending to include projects that involve
construction or a heavy value-add component, while lenders and investors
are also going below traditional thresholds with respect to investment
Full article can be found at: www.privcapre.com/article/mezzanine-debt-risk/Read more
In recent months Dekel Capital has been actively arranging high-leverage loans and financing structures (up to 90% LTC, non-recourse) for clients acquiring value-add and core-plus deals nationwide. We’d like to use this opportunity to share with you some of the market intelligence we’ve gathered.
This financing can be sourced wholly from a single source, debt fund underwriting to a CLO execution, or by placing a senior loan plus mezz/pref equity. These capital sources are focused on business plan execution across all property types and are not constrained by bank leverage metrics, enabling them to fund loans to higher LTC’s.
In one recent assignment, Dekel Capital sourced 90% LTC non-recourse financing (Freddie Floating Rate Loan + Pref Equity) at a sub-6.0% blended rate, non-recourse and fixed for 5 years, for the acquisition of a 300-unit value-add multifamily deal on an underperforming class-B multifamily asset in Southern Florida.
New Capital in the Market: Mezz/Pref Equity for Core-Plus acquisitions
Furthermore, we recently spoke to a new fund that is focused deploying preferred equity or mezz debt (up to 90% LTC) for the acquisition of core-plus (8-11% leveraged IRR) projects in major metropolitan markets. This program is well suited for underperforming properties with either near term lease roll, above market vacancy, significant deferred maintenance, or repositioning. This capital is highly motivated to fund urban/in-fill retail acquisitions.
If you are working on a transaction that would benefit from these types of financings please to contact us for a confidential discussion.Read more
Max Friedman has joined Los Angeles-based real estate investment banking firm Dekel Capital as Senior Vice President where he will focus on arranging debt and equity for the acquisition, development, and refinancing of
commercial real estate assets nationally.
Friedman joins Dekel Capital after two-and-a-half years with Boston Private Bank and Trust Company. As Vice President in the Los Angeles office, Friedman originated commercial real estate loans for bank clients and was also responsible for managing a portfolio of Southern California commercial loans.
Previously, Friedman was an Assistant Vice President at Los Angeles-based commercial real estate firm George Smith Partners, where he worked on structured finance assignments and loan sales. Friedman started his career as an Analyst in the Equity Derivatives department at Goldman Sachs in New York.
Friedman completed, with honors, his undergraduate studies at Tufts University and holds an MBA degree from IESE Business School in Barcelona, Spain and an MIA from the School of International and Public Affairs at Columbia University in the City of New York.Read more
Los Angeles – Dekel Capital, a Los Angeles-based real estate investment banking firm, has arranged an $17 million of permanent debt on behalf of Orange County, CA-based Core Capital Investments for a cash-out refinance of a coastal mobile home park set on approximately 15 acres located in Southern California, announced Dekel Managing Principal Shlomi Ronen.
The non-recourse senior debt, funded by a bank, has a thirty year term and is fixed for seven years with five years of interest only. “The biggest challenge of the deal was that the Sponsors had a single day to pay off their existing loan without having to incur a severe prepayment penalty, as a result we needed to have a flawless execution of the refinance.” says Ronen. Ronen adds, “Our strong relationship with the lender along with upfront underwriting of the asset enabled us to achieve the desired results.”Read more
‘Reversion’ of Units Rented Out in Downturn Is Fresh Sign of Housing Market’s Strength
By Conor Dougherty
Many condominium developers who rode out the real-estate downturn by renting out their units are reverting to for-sale housing, in another sign of the market’s continued recovery over the past year.
Take Amir Haber, a Los Angeles developer who opened his Universal Lofts project at precisely the wrong moment in late 2008, when the stock market was in free fall and home prices were declining at a double-digit pace. Instead of selling off the project’s 67 lofts that range from 2,000 to 2,500 square feet and sit across the highway from Universal Studios, Mr. Haber converted them into high-end rentals that range from about $3,800 to $5,500 a month.
Miami, above, is a market where developers are satisfying demand with new condominiums or ‘reversions’ from…Read more
Universal Lofts in Studio City is one of the apartment complexes to turn to the once popular practice of converting to condos. The trend is far below peak in 2007.
Apartment building owners in Los Angeles and throughout California are once again converting to condos, but not at the torrid pace of 2007, when condo conversion peaked before the Great Recession.
The work-live units at Universal Lofts in Studio City, across the 101 Freeway from Universal Studios, were built in 2008 as condominiums. But with the 2007-09 recession underway, developers turned them into apartments. Now the owners are back with plans for condos.
This complex is one of the first to return to the once popular trend, said Shlomi Ronen, managing principal at Dekel Capital, which arranged the refinancing deal. But this property surely won’t be the last, he said…Read more